| Bonnie & Clyde | Frank Wildhorn | CD | 21 | |
| Jekyll & Hyde | Frank Wildhorn | CD | 18 | |
| Far Away Places: Live at 54 Below | Patti LuPone | Digital Media | 20 | |
| Memory & Mayhem: Live at 54 Below | Norbert Leo Butz | CD | 20 | |
| When I Grow Up: Broadway’s Next Generation – Live at 54 Below | Various Artists | CD | 21 | |
| The Radio in My Head: Live at 54 Below | Aaron Tveit | CD | 23 | |
| Matilda the Musical | Tim Minchin | Digital Media | 26 | |
| Matilda the Musical | Tim Minchin | CD | 24 | |
| Stories... in NYC: Live at 54 Below | Bebe Neuwirth | CD | 19 | |
| Far Away Places - Live at 54 Below | Patti LuPone | CD | 20 | |
| Awakening: Live at 54 Below | Sierra Boggess | CD | 26 | |
| Big Fish | Andrew Lippa | CD | 20 | |
| From Broadway With Love: A Benefit Concert for Sandy Hook | Various Artists | 2×CD | 13 + 13 | |
| A Little Help From My Friends: Live at 54 Below | Jarrod Spector | CD | 24 | |
| Nice Fighting You: A 30th Anniversary Celebration Live at 54 Below | Lynn Ahrens & Stephen Flaherty | 2×CD | 24 + 24 | |
| Live Out Loud: Live at 54 Below | Shapiro Sisters | CD | 25 | |
| The Angel Band Project: An Evening With Norbert Leo Butz | Norbert Leo Butz | CD | 15 | |
| Peter Pan Live! | Mark Charlap; Christopher Walken, Allison Williams | CD | 26 | |
| Liberty: A Monumental New Musical | Jonathan Goldstein | CD | 12 | |
| Side Show: Added Attractions – Live at 54 Below | Henry Krieger | CD | 14 | |
| Bring the Future Faster: Live at 54 Below | Danielle Hope | CD | 19 | |
| The Visit | Kander & Ebb | CD | 22 | |
| Doctor Zhivago: A New Musical | Lucy Simon | CD | 26 | |
| Stopping Time | Isabela Moner | CD | 12 | |
| Matters of the Heart | Patti LuPone | Digital Media | 20 | |
| Stopping Time | Isabela Moner | Digital Media | 12 | |
| A Little Bit Broadway, a Little Bit Rock & Roll: Live at 54 Below | Micky Dolenz | CD | 29 | |
| What About Today? Live at 54 Below | Melissa Errico | CD | 27 | |
| Lost in the Stars: Live at 54 Below | Annaleigh Ashford | Digital Media | 19 | |
| Side Show (Original 2014 Broadway Cast Recording) | Bill Russell | CD | 26 | |
| Nevermore: The Imaginary Life and Mysterious Death of Edgar Allan poe | Various Artists | 2×CD | 11 + 11 | |
| Allegiance | Jay Kuo | CD | 26 | |
| The Color Purple: New Broadway Cast Recording | Brenda Russell, Allee Willis & Stephen Bray | CD | 26 | |
| The Color Purple: New Broadway Cast Recording | Brenda Russell, Allee Willis & Stephen Bray | Digital Media | 26 | |
| Fiddler on the Roof | Jerry Bock & Sheldon Harnick | CD | 20 | |
| Bonnie and Clyde and a Whole Lot of Jazz: Live at 54 Below | Frank Wildhorn and Friends | CD | 17 | |
| Arlington: World Premiere Recording | Polly Pen | CD | 19 | |
| Unattached: Live at Feinstein’s/54 Below | Emily Skinner & Alice Ripley | CD | 22 | |
| Girls, Girls, Girls: Live at 54 Below | Norbert Leo Butz | CD | 27 | |
| Live at Feinstein’s/54 Below | Jay Armstrong Johnson | Digital Media | 22 | |
| Live at Feinstein's/54 Below | Charles Busch with Tom Judson at the piano | CD | 19 | |
| If You Knew My Story: Live at Feistein’s/54 Below | Carmen Cusack | CD | 29 | |
| If You Knew My Story: Live at Feinstein’s/54 Below | Carmen Cusack | Digital Media | 30 | |
| I Have a Voice | Broadway Kids Against Bullying | Digital Media | 1 | |
| From Broadway With Love: A Benefit Concert for Orlando | Various Artists | 2×CD | 18 + 20 | |
| You’re a Good Man, Charlie Brown (2016 Off‐Broadway Cast Recording) | Clark Gesner, Andrew Lippa & Vince Guaraldi | CD | 22 | |
| A Dog Story | Gayla D. Morgan | CD | 14 | |
| Time Reveals | Shapiro Sisters | CD | 5 | |
| I Will Always Love You | Deborah Cox | CD | 8 | |
| Speech & Debate: Original Motion Picture Score | Deborah Lurie | Digital Media | 26 | |
| Anastasia: The New Broadway Musical | Stephen Flaherty | CD | 25 | |
| 2017 Tony Award Season | Various Artists | Digital Media | 15 | |
| Anastasia: The New Broadway Musical | Stephen Flaherty | Digital Media | 25 | |
| The Lightning Thief: The Percy Jackson Musical | Rob Rokicki | Digital Media | 19 | |
| The Lightning Thief: The Percy Jackson Musical | Rob Rokicki | CD | 19 | |
| Don't Monkey With Broadway | Patti LuPone | 2×CD | 20 + 18 | |
| Twisted Broadway, Vol. 1: An A Cappella Album | Blue Jupiter | CD | 12 | |
| 2017 Tony Award Season | Various Artists | CD | 15 | |
| Hamlisch Uncovered | Various Artists | CD | 20 | |
| Once on This Island: The Musical | Stephen Flaherty | CD | 19 | |
| Once on This Island: The Musical | Stephen Flaherty | Digital Media | 19 | |
| My Fair Lady (2018 Broadway Cast Recording) | Lerner & Loewe | CD | 19 | |
| Wild and Free | Jessica Vosk | Digital Media | 14 | |
| 2019 Tony Award Season | Various Artists | Digital Media | 14 | |
| Cleopatra: The Musical Experience | Various Artists | CD | 11 | |
| Dog Man: The Musical | Various Artists | CD | 16 | |
| A Musical About Star Wars (Original Cast Recording) | Various Artists & Billy Recce | CD | 12 | |
| Hey Gurl, It’s Christmas! | Randy Rainbow | Digital Media | 8 | |
| Plays With Music | Brian Stokes Mitchell | CD | 11 | |
| A Never-Ending Line (A Female Song Cycle) | Jaime Lozano | CD | 17 | |
| The Lightning Thief (Karaoke Edition) - EP | Rob Rokicki | Digital Media | 5 | |
| The Lightning Thief: The Percy Jackson Musical | Rob Rokicki | Digital Media | 24 | |
| Yankee Doodle Dandy!: The New George M. Cohan Musical (Studio Cast Recording) | Various Artists | CD | 21 | |
| Losing My Mind: A Sondheim Disco Fever Dream | Various Artists | CD | 12 | |
| Losing My Mind: A Sondheim Disco Fever Dream | Various Artists | Digital Media | 12 | |
| A Killer Party: A New Musical (Original Cast Recording) | Jason Howland, Nathan Tysen& Original Cast of A Killer Party | Digital Media | 20 | |
| If Donald Got Fired | Patti LuPone & Randy Rainbow | Digital Media | 1 | |
| If the Fates Allow: a Hadestown Holiday Album | Jewelle Blackman, Yvette Gonzalez‐Nacer & Kay Trinidad | CD | 14 | |
| If the Fates Allow: a Hadestown Holiday Album | Jewelle Blackman, Yvette Gonzalez‐Nacer & Kay Trinidad | Digital Media | 14 | |
| Live in Concert With the Sydney Symphony Orchestra | Lea Salonga & Sydney Symphony Orchestra | CD | 16 | |
| Rags Parkland Sings The Songs Of The Future (Original Cast Recording) | Various Artists | CD | 15 | |
| Caroline, or Change (2021 Broadway Cast) | Tony Kushner & Jeanine Tesori | CD | 53 | |
| Mr. Biden (Bring My Vaccine) | Randy Rainbow | Digital Media | 1 | |
| Breathe - A New Musical (Original Cast Recording) | Various Artists | Digital Media | 23 | |
| Stone Crossed (Studio Concept Album) | Philip David Stern | (unknown) | 22 | |
| A Little Brains, a Little Talent | Randy Rainbow | Digital Media | 14 | |
| A Little Brains, a Little Talent | Randy Rainbow | CD | 16 | |
| Hex (Highlights from the National Theatre Production) | Jim Fortune, Rufus Norris & National Theatre | Digital Media | 12 | |
| Caroline, or Change (The New Broadway Cast Recording) | Jeanine Tesori & Tony Kushner | 2×CD | 29 + 24 | |
| Assassins (2022 off-Broadway cast) | Stephen Sondheim | Digital Media | 11 | |
| Gay! | Randy Rainbow | Digital Media | 1 | |
| Knoxville, a New Musical (World Premiere Recording) | Stephen Flaherty, Lynn Ahrens | CD | 21 | |
| My Heart Says Go (Studio Cast Recording) | Jorge Rivera‐Herrans | Digital Media | 17 | |
| Camelot | Lerner & Loewe | Digital Media | 19 | |
| Dancing at Lughnasa | Hannah Peel | Digital Media | 10 | |
| Camelot: The 2023 Broadway Cast Recording | Lerner & Loewe | CD | 19 | |
| Guys & Dolls | Various Artists | Digital Media | 34 | |
| Guys & Dolls | Various Artists | CD | 27 | |
| London Tide (World Premiere Recording) | PJ Harvey; Ben Power; National Theatre | Digital Media | 13 | |
| A Leap in the Dark - Live at Feinstein's/54 Below | Arielle Jacobs | CD | 31 | |
