| # | Title | Artist | Length |
|---|
| 1 | Stuck With You (stand-alone version) | Matthew Hydzik, Barrett Martin, Erin Davie & Emily Padgett | 2:20 |
| 2 | Like Everyone Else (role reversal version) | Erin Davie & Emily Padgett | 2:18 |
| 3 | You Should Thank Me Every Day (extended version) | Blair Ross | 1:56 |
| 4 | All in the Mind (acoustic version) | Javier Ignacio | 3:00 |
| 5 | Why Haven’t You Learned Yet? (cut from show) | Henry Krieger | 2:07 |
| 6 | Good We Found You (extended version) | Emily Padgett, Erin Davie, Charity Angél Dawson & Kelvin Moon Loh | 1:03 |
| 7 | Sideshow (cut from show) | Erin Davie & Emily Padgett | 2:55 |
| 8 | Those Two Have Faced So Many Trials (not on OCR) | Ryan Silverman | 0:36 |
| 9 | New Year’s Eve & Proposal (not on OCR) | Ryan Silverman, Erin Davie, Emily Padgett, Matthew Hydzik, Lauren Elder, Blair Ross & Hannah Shankman | 5:14 |
| 10 | Buddy’s Confession (not on OCR) | Matthew Hydzik, Emily Padgett, Erin Davie & David St. Louis | 1:27 |
| 11 | The Choice I Made (cut from show) | David St. Louis | 2:45 |
| 12 | Ready to Play/We Share Everything (mash-up of vaudeville numbers) | Erin Davie, Emily Padgett, Ryan Silverman & Matthew Hydzik | 3:18 |
| 13 | Who Will Love Me As I Am? (ensemble version) | Side Show: Added Attractions Ensemble | 3:38 |
| 14 | I Will Never Leave You (acoustic version) | Emily Padgett & Erin Davie | 3:57 |
