| There's No Place Like Home | All Heart | CD | 10 | |
| Real Talk | Man Overboard | CD | 15 | |
| While You Were Sleeping | The Story So Far | CD | 5 | |
| Small Town EP | At the Edge | CD | 7 | |
| Something for Nothing | Chunk! No, Captain Chunk! | CD | 14 | |
| Stand Tall / Pedestals | Such Gold | CD | 11 | |
| Brand New Me | In Her Own Words | CD | 9 | |
| Keep This to Yourself / Something Left Behind | Transit | CD | 23 | |
| Apparently, I'm Nothing | State Champs | CD | 9 | |
| Holy Shit | Living With Lions | CD | 10 | |
| Gospel | Fireworks | CD | 15 | |
| Under Soil and Dirt | The Story So Far | CD | 14 | |
| Losing Ground / Changes | Think Big! | CD | 10 | |
| All of Hostage Calm | Hostage Calm | CD | 28 | |
| Mixtape | Major League | CD + Digital Media | 11 + 1 | |
| Sleep on It | Ages | CD | 11 | |
| The Lenses | After Tonight | Digital Media | 6 | |
| The Lenses | After Tonight | CD | 6 | |
| Such Gold / A Loss for Words | Such Gold / A Loss for Words | CD | 6 | |
| Separation | Balance and Composure | CD | 15 | |
| It's Better Late Than Never | Handguns | CD | 17 | |
| Tycoon | No Trigger | CD | 11 | |
| Decade | Decade | CD | 10 | |
| Follow Your Bliss: The Best of Senses Fail | Senses Fail | 2×CD | 16 + 4 | |
| Far from Home | Broadside | CD | 10 | |
| Misadventures | Such Gold | CD | 11 | |
| Angst | Handguns | CD | 12 | |
| Broken Jaw | Light You Up | CD | 8 | |
| Hard Feelings | Major League | CD | 13 | |
| The Best Ways to Disappear | Candy Hearts | CD | 10 | |
| A Very New Found Glory Christmas | New Found Glory | CD | 5 | |
| Statues | After Tonight | 7" Vinyl | 2 | |
| Pentimento | Pentimento | CD | 13 | |
| What You Don’t See | The Story So Far | CD | 11 | |
| Pardon My French | Chunk! No, Captain Chunk! | CD | 12 | |
| Everyone That Dragged You Here | Real Friends | CD | 11 | |
| Crooked in My Mind | Koji | CD | 13 | |
| I Won’t Hold This Against You | Light Years | CD | 17 | |
| Jar | Daylight | CD | 16 | |
| Youth | Citizen | CD | 10 | |
| Everything I Used to Trust | In Her Own Words | CD | 10 | |
| Future Fire | Stickup Kid | CD | 16 | |
| The Finer Things | State Champs | CD | 12 | |
| The Light Under Closed Doors | The Swellers | CD | 17 | |
| Before It Caves | A Loss for Words | CD | 16 | |
| "Nothing & Everything" EP | Seasons Change | CD | 8 | |
| The Chronicles of Gnarnia | Gnarwolves | CD | 15 | |
| Wolverines | I Am the Avalanche | CD | 12 | |
| Oh, Common Life | Fireworks | CD | 11 | |
| The Canary in the Birdcage | After Tonight | CD | 12 | |
| The Canary in the Birdcage | After Tonight | 12" Vinyl | 12 | |
| 4 Way Split | A Loss for Words / After Tonight / PVRIS / Wind In Sails | CD | 16 | |
| 2012-2013 Mixtape | Knuckle Puck | CD | 12 | |
| Charmer | Tigers Jaw | CD | 12 | |
| Life Lessons | Handguns | CD | 10 | |
| Go Down in History | Four Year Strong | CD | 5 | |
| colourmeinkindness | Basement | CD | 14 | |
| Colourmeinkindness + Further Sky | Basement | Digital Media | 13 | |
| The Kids Can't Lose | A Loss for Words | CD | 13 | |
| Gnarwolves | Gnarwolves | CD | 10 | |
| Passing Ends | Man Overboard | CD | 22 | |
| There's Nothing Wrong with Me | Major League | CD | 11 | |
| The New Sidewalk | Such Gold | CD | 12 | |
| While I Stay Secluded | Knuckle Puck | CD | 6 | |
| All We've Ever Known | Light You Up | CD | 11 | |
| Supersonic Home | Adventures | CD | 12 | |
| Please Don't Leave | Seasons Change | CD | 11 | |
| Ours Is Chrome | Superheaven | CD | 11 | |
| Disposable Summer | No Good News | CD | 6 | |
| Get Lost, Find Yourself | Chunk! No, Captain Chunk! | CD | 10 | |
| The Story So Far | The Story So Far | CD | 12 | |
| Everybody Is Going to Heaven | Citizen | CD | 11 | |
| Heavy Love | Man Overboard | CD | 12 | |
| Bad Weather | In Her Own Words | CD | 6 | |
| Around the World and Back | State Champs | CD | 13 | |
| Colour Blind | Seaway | CD | 16 | |
| Disenchanted | Handguns | CD | 10 | |
| I’ll See You When I See You | Light Years | CD | 13 | |
| Tired of Tomorrow | Nothing | CD | 12 | |
| The Home Inside My Head | Real Friends | CD | 14 | |
| Unfamiliar | In Her Own Words | CD | 11 | |
| Crises | A Loss for Words | CD | 12 | |
| Heavy Thoughts | For the Win | CD | 10 | |
| Outsiders | Gnarwolves | CD | 14 | |
| Good Nature | Turnover | CD | 13 | |
| Vacation | Seaway | CD | 12 | |
| As You Please | Citizen | CD | 15 | |
| 10 Bass Players Later | Daggermouth | CD | 26 | |
| Cities in Search of a Heart | The Movielife | CD | 10 | |
| Home | Castaway | 7" Vinyl | 2 | |
| Something for Nothing | Chunk! No, Captain Chunk! | Cassette | 14 | |
| Living Proof | State Champs | CD | 15 | |
| One | Homesafe | CD | 13 | |
| Dance on the Blacktop | Nothing | CD | 10 | |
| Island | Living With Lions | CD | 14 | |
| Proper Dose | The Story So Far | CD | 11 | |
| Paint It | Castaway | CD | 6 | |
| You Are Flawed, but You'll Be Fine | rationale. | CD | 17 | |
| A Different Shade of Blue | Knocked Loose | CD | 14 | |
| Altogether | Turnover | CD | 10 | |
