| A Cautionary Tale | | | |
| Apex Predator | | | |
| Beautiful | | - Barrett Wilbert Weed, Katie Ladner, Alice Lee, Jessica Keenan Wynn & Elle McLemore
- Casey Cott, Madelaine Petsch, Camila Mendes, Ashleigh Murray, KJ Apa, Lili Reinhart, Cole Sprouse, Charles Melton, Jordan Connor, Drew Ray Tanner, Zoé de Grand'Maison & Bernadette Beck
- Carrie Hope Fletcher & Original West End Cast of Heathers
| |
| Big Fun | | - Jon Eidson, Evan Todd, Barrett Wilbert Weed, Jessica Keenan Wynn & Alice Lee
- Zoé de Grand'Maison, Casey Cott, Charles Melton, Madelaine Petsch, Vanessa Morgan, Bernadette Beck, KJ Apa, Camila Mendes, Ashleigh Murray, Jordan Connor, Drew Ray Tanner & Lili Reinhart
- Dominic Andersen, Christopher Chung, Carrie Hope Fletcher, Jodie Steele, Sophie Isaacs, T’Shan Williams & Original West End Cast of Heathers
| |
| Blue | | | |
| Dead Girl Walking | | | |
| Dead Girl Walking (reprise) | | | |
| Fight for Me | | | |
| Freeze Your Brain | | | |
| I Am Damaged | | | |
| I’d Rather Be Me | | | |
| Meant to Be Yours | | | |
| Meet the Plastics | | | |
| My World is Burning Down Around Me | | | |
| Our Love Is God | | | |
| Revenge Party | | | |
| Seventeen | | | |
| Seventeen (reprise) | | - Barrett Wilbert Weed, Alice Lee, Katie Ladner & Elle McLemore
- Lili Reinhart, Madelaine Petsch, Camila Mendes, Ashleigh Murray, Vanessa Morgan, Cole Sprouse, KJ Apa, Jordan Connor, Casey Cott, Charles Melton, Zoé de Grand'Maison & Drew Ray Tanner
- Carrie Hope Fletcher, Jenny O’Leary, Sophie Isaacs & Original West End Cast of Heathers
| |
| Someone Gets Hurt (reprise) | | | |
| Where Do You Belong? | | | |
| Yo Girl | | | |
